Is anti-hunting a new form of colonialism?

Giraffe

Is anti-hunting a new form of colonialism? Think about it: where does most of the opposition to trophy hunting in Africa come from? Are Western nations trying to force their will on Africans? 

In this guest blog, John Ogilvie discusses the philosophical implications of Western governments and activists opposing legal hunting programs in Africa. 

Opposition to Hunting in Africa – A New Form of Colonialism – by John Ogilvie

In my last blog, I focused on the outrage surrounding a Parks and Wildlife manager (Jewell Crossberg) who was harassed over photos he had posted from a legal hunting safari in South Africa. I also took the time to briefly articulate how well-regulated hunting can be a useful conservation tool.

Anti-hunting

The man in question has since been removed from his position because of the misguided public outrage, and WA Government officials (including the Premier) did absolutely nothing to try and calm things down or correct the misinformation being spread about hunting in Africa.

Before I continue to the main point of this piece, let’s just briefly point out the hypocrisy on display here.

These same Australian Government officials who are profoundly opposed to African nations managing their wildlife as they see fit have no problem mass culling kangaroos for management reasons or carpet bombing our public lands with 1080 poison.

With that out of the way, I want to discuss some of the philosophical implications of Western governments and activists being publicly opposed to legal, regulated hunting programs in Africa.

What message is being sent to African nations when the governments of Western countries like Australia and the UK openly state that they disapprove of their hunting and wildlife management programs?

Bull elephant stampeding

It seems to convey the message that people in the Western world believe that African nations are inept and that they cannot be trusted to manage their own natural resources (i.e. wildlife), and that the West must step in to show them the ‘right’ way of doing things.

This sentiment seems to be reflective of a type of colonialism, and it is arguably one of the worst variants. For someone who claims to value multiculturalism, Western Australian Premier Mark McGowan seems to be quite intolerant of cultures and governments that do not share his views on wildlife management.

I am not the only person who has noticed this pattern of behaviour from Western government officials and activist groups.

After Botswana’s Government announced that it would lift its ban on elephant hunting in early 2019 due to elephant numbers exploding and an increase in human-wildlife conflict, the country received a significant amount of backlash from Western preservationist groups, individuals within the media and government officials.

Botswana condemned for lifting hunting ban on elephants

Botswana’s President Mokgweetsi Masisi wasted no time in pointing out the absurdity of people in the West trying to dictate how Botswana should manage its wildlife.

Masisi noted that many people outside of Africa speak about it as if, “It’s a big zoo, and they (anti-hunting activists) are the keepers of that zoo.” 

Safari Club International also recently conducted a series of interviews with African government officials and conservationists to get their perspectives on people in the West trying to impose their views on African countries. The sentiment shared by all the interviewees is that African nations know what they are doing when it comes to wildlife management and that anti-hunting campaigns by activists in the West frequently only harm conservation efforts. 

Activists frequently fail to take the human element into account when it comes to matters of wildlife management, and you cannot develop a solid conservation strategy without consulting the people who have to live with wild animals.

Injured lion
Lions are often killed to protect livestock

Indigenous peoples around the world recognise that wildlife needs to be managed and that it can be a valuable resource when looked after properly.

 

About the author: 

John OgilvieJohn Ogilvie is a member of I Am Hunter and a keen hunter. He has a Bachelor of Arts (Major: Politics and International Relations), and a Bachelor of Communications and Media (Major: Film and TV Production). He has recently started writing about his thoughts on hunting

 

If you would like to write articles for I Am Hunter, check out our Contributor Guidelines

See also
Advocate

Can hunting aid Kenya’s economy post Covid?

In 1977, Kenya banned trophy hunting and pinned its economic hopes on tourism, believing photographic tourism to be more sustainable in the long run than hunting tourism. Enter 2020 and a global pandemic that hasn’t just impacted the health of millions of people around the world; it has also decimated the tourism industry. Kenyan based conservation scientist Dennis Ombaki believes there should be a place for well regulated hunting to help Kenya rebuild and provide much-needed economic aid to Africa post Covid-19. 

Read More »
Wildlife for meat
Advocate

Why African lives matter

African lives matter too. An open letter to British celebs has accused them of undermining human rights and putting animals over people by trying to ban hunting.

Read More »

Join I Am Hunter today and help ensure hunting survives